Bunny suits...men in suits...the ambiance of a club atmosphere...a murder. These are the images shown in the pilots and previews for "The Playboy Club", premiering on NBC on Monday, September 19, 2011. Of course, with a name like "The Playboy Club," one can expect a lot of backlash and it has come mainly from the conservative viewers. The show centers on main character Maureen, who comes from a small town and moves to the big city of Chicago. Maureen lands a job at The Playboy Club, a chain club owned by none other than Hugh Hefner.There she meets fellow bunnies and also the patrons who frequent the club. This is a network television show, so the allusion of sex is more important than actually showing the act, well, because they cant. But as soon as the promos hit the web and on-air, the critics began their protests of the show. Hollywood.com (http://www.hollywood.com/news/Is_The_Playboy_Club_Too_Sexy_for_Network_TV/7839742) describes the backlash:
"First, the Salt Lake City NBC affiliate refused to air the series on grounds that it went against their morals and next, acclaimed writer and activist, Gloria Steinem, called for a boycott of the series since it’s based on the string of clubs she once cried out against. Finally, the Parents Television Council requested that NBC remove the buzzy series from its lineup.The argument seems to be wrapped up in the fact that Playboy magazine is technically part of the pornography industry. Which, at face value is an understandably incendiary notion, but that term, which enjoys a rather broad definition these days (you know, “I know it when I see it”) also lends a level of filth to the series that simply isn’t there. The women of the series aren’t prostituting themselves or making sex tapes, they’re wearing tiny outfits and getting into a bit of old fashioned Chicago-style trouble – some of which is more dangerous than sexual. The bunnies may be trotting around in itty-bitty outfits and playing on men’s depraved desires, but isn’t that the same thing we see yearly on The Victoria’s Secret Fashion Show or the Miss Universe Pageant? (Don't fool yourself -- it is.)"
As I go into watching this show for the season, granted it isnt quickly cancelled, I am not interested in the references to sex and "Mad Men." I am interested in the way that the women are portrayed. A blog on http://blog.zap2it.com/frominsidethebox/2011/09/the-playboy-club-an-insult-to-womens-rights-advocates.html refers to the "insult to women:"
"The San Francisco Commission on the Status of Women has issued a non-binding resolution urging NBC and its affiliates to 'replace the program with a series that, instead, depicts women's substantive achievements." The organization is a publicly-funded entity dedicated to securing equal economic, social, political and educational opportunities for San Francisco women.
The resolution, issued in late Aug., says the show "represents a major step backward for women who have struggled to earn an equal place in the workplace, in the community, and at home.'"
I am not totally convinced. I know I mentioned in class that my father told me that this was a time where women were beginning to make more money than the male figures in their life (fathers, brothers, etc.). I think there is some validity to that. Think as you may about women's liberation and women's rights, there is power in money. And there is power in sex. I hope that the show focuses on this topic in some aspect, not just the salacious details that seem to haunt the show. I hope that there is some take-away value in this program so it doesn't become another cliche show that is cancelled within 2 episodes.
I sort of felt this show would surmise to the fate you hope it will not... a cliche that is canceled quickly. I love "remember when" shows that portray a time period, just not one that demoralizes women. And though I could be wrong about this assessment, I feel this show may do just that.
ReplyDeleteExcellent review and examination about the shows potential for success as well as failure.
jdm
I think you are absolutely right Andrea. I'm eager to see how this show plays out. This show goes back to the trends this fall's programs are following, which is a look back in time when times were great.
ReplyDeleteI think NBC knows this, and I believe they will attract the audience it wants to. However, I disagree to a point about the cliche you speak about. To a degree it is cliche, but what show today isn't.
I think NBC is daring to be different with this show, and I hope it doesn't blow up in NBC's face. Only time will tell.
I get how NBC says it will use The Playboy Club to highlight new freedoms and the burgeoning feminist movement of the 1960's. I think that Pan Am hits that note better. I gave The Playboy Club a shot, but I couldn't get past it being about the bunny suits.
ReplyDelete